By: Jessica Bush

The CTO Brief Is a Business Question 

Which problems should a CTO appointment solve, and which belong to the organisation around it? 

CTO bridging the gap

Before searching for a CTO, the board needs to decide which problems the appointment must solve, and which require changes to the organisation around it. 

That distinction is particularly important in electronic trading, where technology decisions directly affect revenue, risk and client experience. A board that asks one appointment to resolve every technology-related challenge risks setting even a capable leader up to fall short. 

Drawing on a recent CTO search for an electronic credit market maker, we examine three decisions that can shape the outcome. 

1. Start with the business problem, not the job description 

A candidate profile describes a person. A commercial problem describes what the business must be able to do in three years that it cannot do today. 

In the search we led, the challenge was more specific than any conventional CTO specification. 

The firm conducted approximately 99.5% of its trading electronically and operated two technology estates at different speeds: a long-established, lower-frequency platform supporting its core credit franchise, and a newer, higher-frequency platform developed for new markets. Roughly 80% of its infrastructure ran in its own data centres, with the remainder in the cloud. Code was released nightly while trading continued. 

The CEO described modernising that estate as rebuilding a highway one lane at a time while traffic keeps moving. 

The firm could not pause revenue-generating operations for a rebuild. It needed a leader capable of sequencing change across two technology environments, protecting its established trading franchise while supporting growth in newer markets. 

This wasn’t simply a modernisation brief. The incoming CTO needed to balance operational stability with investment in the firm’s future capabilities. 

Defining the commercial problem also helps clarify the type of technology leadership required. 

Business challenge 

Leadership profile 

Capability to assess 

Building a new business line, asset class or venue 

The builder 

Moving from concept to production while introducing the controls needed to scale 

Giving an established technology capability greater structure and scale 

The scaler 

Building an engineering organisation without compromising delivery 

Modernising systems supporting live revenue 

The moderniser 

Sequencing change while balancing operational stability and future investment 

These profiles are not mutually exclusive. A firm operating two technology estates may need elements of all three. 

The question is whether one CTO can credibly provide those capabilities, or whether some must be supported by the wider organisation. 

At that point, the brief stops being solely a hiring question and becomes an organisational one. 

2. Decide what the CTO owns — and what they don’t 

No CTO brings every capability a trading business needs. The board’s decision is which capabilities must sit with the CTO and which can be provided elsewhere in the leadership team. 

Some belong with the CTO by definition: technology strategy and architecture, sequencing change, and building an engineering organisation capable of delivering it. 

Others can be shared. Deep asset-class knowledge, for example, may already exist with heads of trading and quantitative research. The board must decide how much domain expertise the CTO needs personally, and where they can draw on others. 

Partnership works only if it is designed: shared objectives, explicit decision rights where technology and trading meet, and accountability that follows the capability. 

A board that relies on a domain partnership without defining it has simply moved the gap somewhere less visible. 

This decision also shapes the market a firm can search. 

In this search, we presented seven shortlists comprising 36 candidates over approximately three months. Eleven met the CEO, and eight progressed to group interviews. 

The search considered three broad talent pools: senior sell-side technology leaders, leaders from front-office FinTech and technology vendors, and buy-side technologists ready to step into a broader leadership role. 

Each offered a different balance of domain expertise, technology leadership and experience operating at scale. 

“The strongest candidates didn’t necessarily meet every requirement on paper. Across the different shortlists, we were looking at leaders with very different backgrounds and strengths. The important question was which capabilities the CTO needed to bring personally, and where the business already had the expertise to support them. Getting that distinction right allowed us to assess a broader range of candidates without compromising on what the role actually required.” 

Joyce McCarthy,  Head of Research at EC1 Executive 

A firm that expects every capability to exist within one individual may unnecessarily narrow its search. Equally, widening the candidate pool without defining how capability gaps will be addressed risks creating problems after appointment. 

The strongest brief is not necessarily the one with the longest list of requirements. It is the one that distinguishes between what is essential in the CTO and what the organisation can credibly provide. 

3. Test the reality of the role, not just the candidate 

By the final stage of a search, the firm has usually tested the candidate thoroughly. A further test is whether both sides understand the operating reality of the role. 

The interview feedback in this search was revealing. 

The reservations interviewers raised most often weren’t about technology choices. They concerned how a candidate would operate in this particular business: prioritising a substantial development backlog with a lean team, moving from quarterly release cycles to nightly ones, leading an estate that runs predominantly on its own infrastructure, and adapting to a smaller, close-knit firm. 

Those are mandate questions as much as capability questions, and they cut both ways. 

A candidate who misjudges the operating reality is as likely to be disappointed as the firm. A technically capable leader may have delivered successful transformation programmes elsewhere, but that experience needs to translate into the investment appetite, pace of change and organisational structure of the business they are joining. 

Before the technical rounds, we provided finalists with detailed preparation guides covering the technology estate, the business functions it supports and the firm’s hybrid infrastructure. 

Later, the CEO invited finalists to examine the business in depth before any offer, making clear that difficult questions would be welcomed. Part of our role was helping finalists take that invitation at face value and raise concerns while they could still be resolved. 

The mandate itself should be explicit: decision rights, appetite for investment, the pace of change, and what success looks like at twelve months and at three years. 

Surfacing concerns before appointment gives both sides the opportunity to resolve expectations before delivery begins. 

Five questions for boards and CEOs 

  1. What must the business be able to do in three years that it cannot do today? What technology and operational constraints stand in the way? 
  2. Which problems should the CTO own? Which require changes to the organisation or support from the wider leadership team? 
  3. Where will deep domain expertise sit? How will that partnership be designed across technology, trading and other functions? 
  4. Does the search reflect those decisions? Are we considering the full range of leadership backgrounds capable of delivering the mandate? 
  5. Do both sides understand the operating reality? Are expectations around accountability, investment, pace of change and measures of success aligned? 

 

A CTO appointment in financial markets is only partly a decision about a person. The rest is a decision about the organisation that person will lead. 

Get In Touch

For further support, insights, tips and marketing intelligence for leadership teams, follow our LinkedIn page dedicated to EC1 Executive and get in touch with our team of specialists.

Executive Search Team

Jamie Cole FinTech CEO

Jamie Cole

CEO & Co-Founder

Netan Director North America

Netan Rosenthal

Managing Partner

Joyce

Joyce McCarthy

Head of Research

Summia

Summia Wise

Principal

Nic Wylie

Nic Wylie

Research Principal

APPLICATION

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Max. file size: 1 GB.