Executive Summary
COO tenure within the FTSE 100 has fallen by 36% since 2023. What was once an average of 4.2 years is now 2.7 years in 2025. Global figures mirror this pattern, with large listed firms averaging around 3.2 years and the S&P 500 at roughly 3.25 years. CEO tenure often stretches to 6 to 8 years, and CFOs typically hold five to seven. This widening gap signals a clear trend. COOs are increasingly hired to deliver a transformation cycle that lasts about three years, then move on to new challenges, often stepping into CEO roles.
In 2024, 22% of incoming CEOs previously held COO positions. Operational experience, supported by AI and data transformation, is now regarded as ideal preparation for top leadership. Turnover at the senior level is also at a historic high. This creates both urgency and opportunity for fintech boards. The sector moves quickly. Regulation stays fluid. Innovation cycles are short. Leadership choices, therefore, carry amplified impact.
This raises a central question. Should the next generation of leaders be nurtured internally, or should external expertise be brought in to accelerate progress?
Succession planning is becoming a core part of hiring strategy. Leadership teams are investing in structured development programmes, identifying successors earlier, and giving senior professionals the range of exposure they need. The issue is no longer whether leadership development matters, but how to design a system that drives measurable business value rather than another programme with weak return.
The most competitive fintech firms take a blended approach. They build internal pipelines rooted in culture and organisational knowledge. They use targeted external hires to fill capability gaps. That balance creates both continuity and healthy disruption.
The Case for Home-Grown Leadership
Internal development builds depth. It preserves organisational memory, strengthens cultural alignment, and increases loyalty. In fintech, where success depends on trust, product understanding, and regulatory awareness, internal leaders often move faster because they already understand how decisions are made.
There are risks. Without exposure to new thinking, organisations can drift into groupthink. Innovation slows quietly. Market signals become harder to spot.
Netan Rosenthal – Managing Partner at EC1 Executive discusses this further:
“Many high-potential internal successors are held back not by capability but by gaps in leadership development. Without structured programmes, mentorship, rotational assignments, or stretch projects, promising talent often hits a ceiling. They gain depth in a single area but do not get the cross-functional experience required for senior roles. High-performing fintechs take a different approach. They invest early, provide clear development plans, create meaningful stretch opportunities, and benchmark progress against established frameworks such as CIPD or ATD. Structure, exposure, and consistent measurement turn internal potential into readiness for complex operational and strategic leadership.”
What works for internal pipelines
- Clear leadership pathways supported by mentorship, rotational assignments, and stretch projects.
- Cross-functional exposure across product, data, risk, and compliance.
- Learning frameworks from CIPD or ATD that add rigour and track progress.
Firms that excel build breadth deliberately. They move future leaders across teams so they develop agility and resilience. Those capabilities matter most when markets shift or regulations tighten.
The Case for Headhunted Leaders
External leadership brings new perspective. A strong external hire offers insight from other fintechs, global financial institutions, or high-growth tech companies. They challenge assumptions, benchmark performance, and often accelerate transformation in areas such as AI infrastructure, risk strategy, ESG reporting, or international scale.
There are limits. Integration slows when cultural fit is not assessed properly. Retention drops when expectations are unclear or when the mandate is vague.
Jamie Cole – CEO and Head of EC1 Executive adds:
“Boards look externally when specific capabilities are needed quickly or when internal pipelines cannot meet strategic demands. External hires often outperform internal candidates in roles that require a fresh perspective, such as digital transformation, AI-driven operations, or large-scale data infrastructure work. Integration however remains critical. Cultural adaptability and structured onboarding determine how quickly a leader gains traction. The most successful organisations pair clear mandates with strong support, helping external leaders accelerate transformation while embedding effectively within the team.”
Best practices for external hires
- Evaluate both technical expertise and cultural adaptability.
- Define transformation goals clearly so impact can be measured.
- Use structured onboarding and pair new leaders with internal mentors.
When done well, external hires lift the overall leadership standard rather than operating in isolation.
Emerging Leadership Competencies for Fintech Success
Whether leaders are developed internally or hired externally, the competency profile is shifting. Research from professional bodies such as CIPD, ATD, GARP, and fintech associations highlights several priorities.
The next generation of leaders needs:
- Digital and data literacy. Understanding how analytics, AI, and infrastructure shape strategy.
- Regulatory and risk intelligence. Navigating multi-market compliance as firms scale.
- Change leadership. Guiding teams through continuous transformation.
- Stakeholder communication. Managing boards, investors, regulators, and technical teams with clarity.
- Resilience and agile decision-making. Responding effectively when conditions move faster than expected.
- Commercial awareness. Reading the market and anticipating customer and revenue shifts.
Fintech leadership is no longer defined solely by functional expertise. It is defined by adaptability, judgement, and the ability to operate across disciplines.
Designing a Balanced Leadership Pipeline
The strongest fintech firms treat leadership development as a system. Internal talent is identified early and developed intentionally. External hiring is used selectively to bring new thinking and fill capability gaps.
In practice, this looks like:
- Succession planning that maps internal readiness against future skill demands.
- Rotational experiences that reduce silos and build breadth.
- External benchmarking and search insight that shows how the firm compares to high-performance peers.
It is not an either/or problem. The balance is what creates resilience.
Strategic Takeaways for Executives
- Audit your pipeline. Identify capability gaps against your transformation roadmap.
- Invest where outcomes are measurable. Leadership development must tie directly to business goals.
- Blend experience and potential. Build internal agility while using selective external hires for emerging or complex needs.
- Support integration properly. Give new leaders clarity, structured onboarding, mentorship, and access to decision-makers.
- Treat leadership development as strategic infrastructure, not an optional programme.
Conclusion
Most organisations already have frameworks and models. What they often lack is space for leaders to recognise what is happening beneath the surface. Effective development is not only about content. It is about building the conditions for awareness, adaptability, and sound judgment.
In a fintech landscape defined by rapid change and regulatory complexity, leadership strategy must be intentional and evidence based. Firms that balance internal continuity with external challenge are best positioned to innovate, manage risk, and shape the next stage of financial evolution.
EC1 Executive partners with boards and C‑suite leaders to design leadership pipelines that reflect these realities, helping fintech organisations build high‑performing teams prepared for the future of financial innovation. For further support with C‑suite and leadership hires, please get in touch with our Global Executive Search team.
Executive Search Team
CEO & Co-Founder
Managing Partner
Head of Research
Principal
Research Analyst
